Estados Gerais da Psicanálise: Second World Meeting - Rio de Janeiro, 2003
Theme 5: The contemporary subjectivities.
Theme 5.e.: Violence and destructivity in our times.
Is there any way out to violence and destructivity?
Bárbara Conte 2
The objective of this paper is to examine the subjectivity production and the constitution of the psyche
to the light of violence that characterizes our time. The subjectivity is comprehend from the post-
modernity and the constitution of the psyche is include from the problems constitute points to ponder
in the contemporary psychoanalytic thought: the masochism, the traumatic and the joy. In our daily
practice, we find out narcissist forms of the psychosomatic manifestations and the self-destructing
: subjectivity production, constitution of the psyche, masochism, traumatic, joy.
The objective of this paper is to examine the subjectivity production and the
constitution of the psyche to the light of violence that characterizes our time. The
production of subjectivity, in our days, has to do with violence, as well as the
constitution of the psyche, that rests on the traumatic of how seduction registers in
the child prevailing the passivity. In that context, we see masochism as a starting
condition in the individual's life and it should be transposed so that the individual
Modernity / post-modernity in the constitution of subjectivity
The theories of the modernity are focused on a rational individual,
autonomous, authoritarian. The rationality of the modernism, in its bureaucratic and
commercial version, brought about the objective of rupture, the transgressive daring
1 Paper sent to the Second General States of Psychoanalysis WorldEncounter. Rio de Janeiro. October 2003.
2 Psychoanalyst. PhD in Psychology, Autonomous University of Madrid. Memberof Núcleo de Estudos Sigmund Freud.
that innovates, challenges and gives way to the creative and collective. Post-
modernism arises as a reaction to that state of things, trying to revalue the individual
and the differentiation process. In other words, the individual is placed in relation to
other–similar–and their historic process is engendered starting from that necessary
The reactions to the paradigm of the modern era are proposed in several
ways, by several authors. Jacques Derrida proposes a radical “decentralization of the
individual”, stating that the texts do not have authors with defined objective and
intention; that the language does not have speakers with stable identities. There
cannot be a privileged reading of a text or of any other cultural practice, with an
authenticity and universality certificate. Neither an author nor a reader, neither an
agent nor subject can be the privileged conveyer of the meaning. However, was it
reached in our culture? We are still tied up to competence and perform principles that
place us in a subjected position. Therefore, an indispensable condition of our life is at
risk: the recognition
that presupposes the alterity.
Krishan Kumar3 tells us about the post-modernity that “the idea of culture and
national identity is attacked on behalf of minority cultures: ethnic groups, of religious
sects and specific community cultures, based on age, sex or sexuality. It promotes
the “policy of the difference” (p.132). The post-modern architecture follows this idea
and the emphasis is placed on small-scale projects, connecting people and
neighborhoods and aiming at the development of the ethos
in certain places and
The individual, this way, should find themselves in the likeness and in the
differences that might place them in their own place, not in a selfish one, but in a
solidary and sociable. However, it is not what we verify in our daily practice, neither
in the group coexistence, nor in our clinic. The subject -decentralized from the alterity
and from the difference- gives way to the subject of the apathy and of the indifference
that invades the intellectual and the social relationships. The consumption paradigm
tends to put obstacles in the socialization of opportunities, since working, earning
3 KUMAR, K. Da Sociedade pós–industrial à pós–moderna. Novas Teorias sobreo mundo contemporâneo. Rio de Janeiro. Jorge Zahar Editor. 1997, p.132.
money and consuming take the whole time. The shopping malls become the main
places for meeting people. The city is fragmented into three great pieces, which
interact in an external way: the business side, the residential rich residential side, and
the ghettos. People ignore each other; they become stranger and hostile to each
The paradigm of solidarity or hospitality became the one of detachment; the
community and local accomplishments give way to the individualistic consumption.
This is the violence competition's yeast. The only one seen is the one who has
purchase power. The one who does not have this purchase power becomes invisible
and, therefore, they seek -in a violent way- for their visibility and their pleasures.
There seems to be a distance between what we are told by the culture intellectuals
and what we observe in our institutions (families, groups, psychoanalytic societies).
The violence experiences of our world are built-in in the subjectivity
production. Marilena Chauí5 says, “I don't worry so much about new subjectivity
forms, but with new sociability forms, because it is in them that a subjectivity is
modeled and shaped.” Therefore, the sociability procedures in our culture are
permeated by the expression of the religious fanaticism, by the sex and violence
messages in television and in the media, by the constant consumption appeals and
by the individuals’ lack of commitment before the world. Such subjectivity processes6
are translated into the importance given to the consumption, into the need to ascend
socially–“to rise in the life - and into the passivity before problem solution, which is
transferred to the other (whether it is the State or “Superior”). We have the recent
example, where although the international appeal against the war, against violence
as violence reprisal, President Bush attacked Iraq and despised not only the
international appeal but also UNO's. Law force is what stops violence in the most
varied expressions of power, and this force has been weakened.
4CASTORIADIS, C. La cuestión de la democracia. In: Zona Erógena.
RevistaAbierta de psicoanálisis y pensamiento contemporáneo. Buenos Aires, n.
5CHAUÍ, M. Comentários. In: Conferências sobre subjetividades.
São Paulo:Instituto Sedes Sapientiae, 1995, p.18-25.
In subjectivity or in sociability, the recovery of the historical connections makes
possible the representation of a problem in a public level and the knowledge of its
meanings in a private level. The intersection of the psychoanalysis with the social
happens here, the intersections of the private with the public, the individual with their
pairs as well. The recovery of the law–and its execution- happens not only at a
private but also at a public level. The law subject is in compensation for the
transgression, the perversity in all its dimensions.
It is necessary to redefine the perversion concept, because “it is neither a
zone violation, nor a way the genitality is practiced, but articulating, in the sexual
scene, the encounter with another human being.”7 We can broaden this concept and
to think that the impossibility of the encounter with the other does not only append in
the sexual scene, but also in the intersubjectivty one, in the relationship with the
other (exteriority). I take Joel Birman's8 idea when he says, “that what characterizes
the auto-centralization of the subjectivity in the narcissism culture is exactly the
exteriorization excess”. It is the show and performance demand. The so-call "out-of-
themselves" individual is a consequence of post-modernity that legitimates and it
values the perverse forms of enjoying that end the legitimated project of subjectivity.
These two ideas reinforce the concept that the encounter with the other can only be
possible in a joyful context, where the other is the one who has to legitimate the
transgression; however, he/she is prevented of settling as an individual who
determines the own intersubjective action limits. This way, the relationship is set in a
Problems in the Constitution of the Psyche
“Knowing that one knows is not enough to characterize the human individual,
more exactly this possibility of the human individual that is the reflexibility (.) it is for
6COIMBRA, C. Doutrina de Segurança Nacional e produção de subjetividade.
In: Clínica e Política
e Violação dos Direitos Humanos
. TeCorá. Instituto Franco Basaglia. Rio de Janeiro. 2002.
7 BLEICHAMR, S. Por um balanço em direção ao futuro da psicanálise. In:Psicanálise e Universidade.
Revista do Núcleo de Estudos e Pesquisa em
Psicanálise. Programa de Estudos Pós-graduados em Psicologia Clínica.
Pontifícia Universidade Católica de São Paulo, número 14. Abril de 2001.
8BIRMAN, J. Mal-estar na atualidade. A psicanálise e as novas formas desubjetivação. Civilização Brasileira. Rio de Janeiro. 1999.
a historic creation that this possibility becomes an effective reality: it means, there
certainly is a auto-creation of the subjectivity.” (Castoriadis, 1992)
From social to personal, the condition of the historic creation arises the
subjectivity process. In the constitution of the psyche we find points that also give
support to that discussion and those problems constitute points to ponder in the
contemporary psychoanalytic thought: the masochism, the traumatic and the joy
make think why violence and abuse increase in our daily practice under narcissist
and authoritarian forms of constituting the individual, as well as the multiple surgical
surgeries, the abuse of medicines, the psychosomatic manifestations and the self-
Masochism and sexuality / reflexibility
The human sexuality is essentially traumatic, and the masochism is in the
heart of sexuality. The constitution of the psyche is also marked by the intrusion of
another one/similar who registers in a traumatic way. This primary movement, which
is structural and defensive, turns into a masochistic disposition that either deals with
According Freud10, until 1924, the masochism was secondary to the sadism.
However, it can be understood as a first movement, a primordial stage that
corresponds to the return to itself, to the own body [auto-erotism], being the pleasure
and the pain in the same psychic system as a condition of erogenous satisfaction.
That corresponds to a first stage - in that we emphasize the fact of hurting, self-
punishment movement, where “we find the return to the own person without the
passivity to a new one” and that is a reflexive
That reflexive movement implies, firstly, the registration of the sexual traumatic
in the child, as the instinct is engendered and as the passage of the instinct through
the object happens. This movement is made up of the seduction, the dissolution in
9 The ideas developed in these three items, which I call them "problems",are developed in the book Prazer e Dor. O masoquismo e a sexualidade
, of my
authorship. Porto Alegre. Criação Humana Publishers. 2002.
the translation road and of a new unit that arises, which is the institution of the
instinct, through the return mechanism to the own person11
. Under this perspective,
the child is an object before another individual, from a passive intrusion position, and
in the transformation of the passive to the active, that process has an intermediate
phase in which there is a return to the own person (object change), where the aim
has turn itself reflexive (making oneself suffer).
From this first moment on, the experienced registrations are getting complex,
through successive reflexibility movements or, in another words, the mediation of the
seduction is going on and this determines the effectiveness of the traumatic and it is
a mark of the transition of the passive to the active.
Starting from Freud's theory on the traumatism, it is, the precocious paternal
seduction and the amount of energy that invades the protective-shield membrane -
creating effraction- and I introduce Jean Laplanche's contributions related to the
generalized seduction. Seduction, in this conception, is enlarged long after the
factual, being constituted in the message interference of sexual character in the child,
which becomes enigmatic and traumatic for the excitement excess that contains, for
the strange and untranslatable that are for the child. That is why the massage needs
psychic procedure. Masochism, in the first Freudian conception, is beside anaclisis-
seduction, it means, seduction is what propels sexuality and then the formula used by
Laplanche that "the truth of anaclisis is seduction".
The masochistic disposition is settled between traumatism and death instinct
limits. That disposition gathers: a) the excitement that places the child passive; b) the
precocious satisfaction and pain experiences in an incipient psyche in that the topical
differentiation begins to happen. That process infers the constitution of the topical
psychic, of the ego and in new pleasure ways that arise. The masochism is removed
from a biological and secondary conception of the sadism, and it is placed in a first
10 FREUD, S. (1915) OC.AE. Pulsión y destinos de pulsión. v14, p. 123.
11 This mechanism is mention in Pulsão e destinos da pulsão
as one of theprimary destinies of the repression. Then, in Problema econômico domasoquismo, this notion is included as inherent movement of repression inthe individual's constitution.
From this point of view, masochism finds an own sexual constitution code in
metapsychology and turns transformation possible. It becomes a primary pleasure
type that corresponds to a masochistic disposition which aim is to deal with traumatic
and desertion, through sexual representation, theorization and repression. From the
perspective of organizing itself as a type of joy, later manifest itself as way of
organization of pathologies, where the individual themselves inflict suffering,
Death Instinct and traumatism / passivity
The “economic problem” takes place when the pain and the displeasure can
stop being warnings to constitute the aim, the pleasure principle is paralyzed and the
life guardian narcotized. As Freud has been joining this paradox and trying to explain
to elucidate it, modifying his theory of the masochism, we could think that the
masochistic pleasure turns into a pleasure pattern. It is about an effraction effect, it is
about the traumatic that places the individual in a passive and masochistic condition.
The traumatic is reality excess, an amount that needs to process, to take a
psychic way, in order to be organized. The relationship between the immediate12 and
the traumatism takes place when the excess happens. Reality excess -in this case- is
the seduction, and it is lived as traumatic. The repetition compulsion, in its incessant
tendency to retake what it is lived as excess, becomes a mediate possibility among
the traumatic, the pain and the sexuality making conditions for the individual to have
the possibility to deal with the pain and the pleasure in different fields.
This way, the death instinct (trieb) and the masochism would be in correlation,
however governed by different mechanisms. What is left in the death instinct, which
is lived passively, will turn active in the compulsion to repeat. The masochism, as
excitement that registers the individual in the field of the sexuality, will have its way of
12. Breast-feeding experiences are registered in the body and they arelinked to the real impressions (realität). Freud named “material reality”those registers in the body and the real impression. Realität, or immediatereality, merely belongs to the empiric order, based on the experience,being for that denominated factual reality or objective.
acting psychically as mechanisms the return to the own person and the
transformation in the opposite, in the mediation and in the historic temporality.
On the other hand, the eroticism of the pain takes the destiny of the joy, of an
unsuccessful sexuality, because it is based on traumatic seduction ways that
generates effraction and pain that become registrations on the erogenous body and
in the psyche in an outstanding, destructive, misplaced manner. These are
anachronistic types of repetition, not historic and that take to the interference of the
sexual concept that do not allow either the translation or the repression. They are
also kinds of border pathologies and of pathologies in the body, such as infertility,
cancer and anorexia, which work in the field of the previous mechanisms of
From joy to fantasy: expropriation of the ownership
The word joy has some meanings of which I enhance the ownership notion of
some thing one enjoys and from where one gets pleasure.
Joy, in the psychoanalytic meaning, comes from two sources: one, which its
origin lays on the opposition to the desire concept; the other, which starts from
Genuss's sense, coming from Hegel's text, in which there is a difference between
desire and joy when he says that, in the desire, an object is suppressed (aufgheben
and another object is substitutes in its place; while in the joy situation, the object is
postponed and retained, becoming an ideal13. Joy captures the object in a
continuous way of pleasure. Lacan says it is not the law that prevents the individual
access to the joy, it is " the pleasure that introduces in joy its limits, the pleasure as
life connection, incoherent, until another prohibition, an undeniable one, rises from
the regulation discovered by Freud as primary process and pertinent law of
pleasure"14. Joy turns into insatiable enjoyment, in which the pleasure
principle/displeasure does not occur like a kind of satisfactory discharge.
13 HEGEL, F. O sistema da vida ética. Translated from French by J.
Taminiaux. Georg Lasson, p.116.
The connection between joy and masochism is indicated by the body and by
the appropriation notion. Joy and pain give a reciprocal condition one another and
the dimension of the individual subjection to each other can be thought. For that, I
refer to the notion of joy as " usufruct ", in the meaning of “enjoyment of the thing
while it is an appropriation object and hiding in the theory that the appropriation is an
expropriation, because something is only mine while there are others for whom
"mine" is someone else's. Only what it is possessed, juridically speaking, can be
enjoyable, and in order to fully possess it is necessary for the other to give up their
Starting from the notion that joy is the usufruct of something as the
appropriation of what doesn't belong to me, all the other's “input” can be thought as
either self-conservative cares, like Freud tells us, or as enigmatic messages, as
Laplanche thinks, it is a way of object appropriation, in our case, the incipient
individual. Such appropriation is made by the seduction, body joy.16
The subject-object concern rises again and it gains force when the relationship
between joy and masochism is thought. When the subject and the object are united,
according to Lacan17: “the subject takes the object role, (and) it is exactly that what
holds the reality of the situation up -called sado-masochist instinct, and it is just in a
point - in the masochistic situation itself. It is in it that the subject is object of another’s
will, that not only closes itself, but also it constitutes the sado-masochist instinct".
The course from joy to fantasy is described by Freud when theorizes about the
seduction the child is exposed to. In the text "A child is beaten"18, the author
interrelates the instincts, the bringing of fantasies to light, the masochism and he
14 LACAN, J. (1995), Subversion du sujet et dialectique du désir. In:Ècrits.
Paris. Seuil, p.821.
15 BRAUNSTEIN, Néstor. (1990), Goce. México. Siglo Veintiuno, p.16.
16 The expropriation movement is given by the possibility that excitements,passing through the pulsional circuit, make the conversion from passive toactive, providing to the ego to translate and to repress the messages ofthe sexual excess of the other, heading to the subject's constitution. Theexpropriation turns the subject and the object different from one another,meaning the renouncement to the usufruct of the child's seduced body.
17 LACAN, J. (1973). Les quatre concepts fondamentaux da psychanalyse.
Paris, Seuil, p.168.
introduces, not by chance, the scene that causes the ghost of "being beaten by the
father". That scene supposes an another that, when exercising the action of beating,
he places the individual in the condition of receiving an excitement amount that
needs to satisfy itself actively in a passive, masturbatory, auto-erotic way.
The ghost of " being beaten by the father because he likes me" contains a
conversion, which is essential to mention. The premise that "I am beaten because I
am a bad child "turned into" they beat me because they like me" and later repressed.
Freud says that from the course of a formulation to the other, the masochistic
condition s becomes the origin not only of perversion, but also of infantile sexual
Through this Freudian's thought, the fantasy, which becomes unconscious in
the individual, is the one of "being beaten by the father", and, in that perspective, the
fantasy is basically masochistic.19 The fantasies are mediations, expropriation ways
of the other one that they are formed in the course of the child's subjection before the
interference of the adult's sexuality, until the theorizations. The fantasies get, at the
beginning, that masochistic nature, exactly because of the child's subjection condition
that has to let its original objects go. The fantasies decipher the enigma of the
It is, then, the way in which the individual leaves the submitted masochistic
position. That way is the way of the abandonment, detachment, loss of the original
objects. It can be said that this is the task Freud refers to along his work so that the
child becomes an individual, and he points out this statement when he says “we have
discerned a condition for the reality exam to be instituted: objects have to be lost that
19 This theme can be studied in O livro da dor e do amor
, by J.D. Nasio. Rio
20. The precursory models of the interference are: in Totem and Taboo (1913)the oral-cannibalistic form of the primary object–love=devour, as a resultof unconscious hostility projection on the demons, in the taboo of thedeads, theory adopted by Melanie Klein as the identification origin; inLeonardo da Vinci and an childhood memory (1910) a first connection isdescribed “the mother, that breastfeeds the child, or better: from whom thechild sucks, became a vulture that introduces its tail in the child'smouth” passive homosexual fantasy, of sexuality, “introduced” by themother-vulture in the baby. Pattern for Laplanche’s generalized seductiontheory.
formerly sought a satisfaction in the object (real)”21. The mediation process or the
reflexibility one is the transformation that takes into account the object, but it is
transformed into ego through the abandonment of the object. When the maintenance
of the subjection position happens, the child does not accomplish the mediation; they
do not let the original objects go, turning impossible their individual historic place.
Not any the instincts have to be "tamed
” but also the identification primary
objects that provide the structuring of the ego have to be abandoned. The loss of the
primary objects is the impression condition and the secondary identification. What are
the possibilities left to get off such a passive and dominated by the other position?
Love is the substitute of the lost object and, when the individual is not captured by
the joy of the other, he/she can be placed as the one who sees, the one who speaks,
The law force returns here as a not capturing love, as well as indicating the
interdicted, as the dominance limit (either by the incestuous desire, or by the
homicidal one). This is the condition to the course to form the symbolic alterity, in
other words, the way of registering the other in itself without being captured in that
other one, being the other “present in me”, but “different from me”23. The loss of the
object of Oedipal desires extolled by Freud establishes the symbolism, abstraction
condition. The ideal is inside the subject. The recognition presupposes the alterity, an
individual before the other. From that point on, the recognition of the anatomical
sexual distinction and the descapture or not alienation, through law happens.
The formula ego=ego is reflexive and identifiable, because it places the
individual in front of themselves. The conversion from the passive to the active
21 FREUD, S. (1925) OC.AE. A negação. V.19. In this text Freud makes thedifference between the subjective and the objective. The subjective isgiven through the adverse judgment act, that either affirms or deniesthought contents and that is an intellectual substitute of repression. Onthe other hand, the objective is the examination of the reality, more than“finding -in the objective perception (real)- an object that corresponds tothe represented, to convince oneself that is still there”(p.255).
22 . Freud, in A child is beaten
, points out the nature that the beating
scene that causes pleasure is lived by another one. The individual isexcluded.
23 To learn more about this, see Lévinas, E. Entre nós
. Ensaios sobre aalteridade.
Rio de Janeiro. Vozes. 1997.
makes the individual abandon the position of loving themselves, introducing new
equation "I-another", time for repression and for the law that makes possible the
secondary identifications. It is the course from reflexibility to alterity. The historic
individual is recognized through the identification and differs of the other through the
To end I would like to enhance the ideas I have tried to present. The topical
intersubjective paradigm, which allows the individual a solidary attitude before
another one, is defined as reflexibility and mediation of the reality. It is taken into
consideration the law force, which settles itself as a limit and love condition. The
subjectivity emerges from this field of conflict and solutions. The paradigm of
perversion, seen as the impossibility of the encounter and exteriority excess, is
defined by joy, by the immediate of the scene and by the fact. The result is the
indifference for the other and the selfishness, stanched ways of the capacity of
constituting the alterity. They are two positions that trace different ways in living the
culture in its types of violence, and they take different directions before the subject's
Catherine Ulbricht, PharmD, MBA(C), Column Editor Synonyms/Common Names/Related Substances: Beladona, belladone, belladonnae herbae pulvis standardisatus, belladonna herbum, belladonna leaf, belladonna pulvis normatus, belladonnae folium, belladonna radix, belladonne, deadly nightshade, deadly nightshade leaf, devil’s cherries, devil’s herb, die Catherine Ulbricht is affiliated with Massachu
anaLYtiK WAssEr Parameter Preis (CHF) Wasserlöslicher Anteil, Abdampfrückstand Parameter Preis (CHF) (pH, Sulfat, Ammonium, Magnesium, kalklösende Kohlensäure) Parameter Preis (CHF) Oxidierbarkeit (Kaliumpermanganat-Verbrauch) BMG ENGINEERING AG 7 anaLYtiK WAssEr Parameter Preis (CHF) Parameter Preis (CHF) 8 BMG ENGINEERING AG anaLYtiK W