Polyploidy in Sugar Beets Induced by the Use
of Colchicine, Ethyl Mercury Phosphate,
and Other Chemicals1
F R A N K F . L Y N E S A N D C . D . H A R R I S 2
Chemically induced polyploids, particularly those of economic
plants, have attracted considerable attention during the past 4 years.
Colchicine has been widely used and is now generally accepted as a
standard chemical for this purpose. Other chemicals and treatments
have been investigated, but their application and use has not been as
general as the use of colchicine.
This paper presents the results of a detailed greenhouse experi-
ment evaluating the use of colchicine for inducing polyploidy in sugar beets by the seed-soaking method. There are also included the results of numerous preliminary experiments involving the use of ethyl mer-cury phosphate, sulfanilamide, sulfapyridine, calcium phosphate, and X-ray treatments.
Colchicine Seed-Soaking Treatments
Our attempts to produce polyploidy in sugar beets during the
spring of 1938 by the use of colchicine as suggested by Blakeslee and Avery (3) were not very successful since all of the polyploids pro-duced either reverted to normal or died.3
The following experiment was conducted to evaluate the col-
chicine seed-soaking procedure. Solutions of colchicine, of from 0 to 2.0 percent were utilized and 50 seedballs of a commercial variety of sugar-beet seed were soaked in each of these solutions for from 1 to 6 days at room temperature and then planted. Dry seed was also plant-ed as a check.
The development of the seedlings was closely observed and counts
were made on the number of plants produced. The number of poly-
ploids present in each lot was determined by their thickened hypocotyl, and all diploids present were removed. Periodic microscopic examina-
tions of the size of the stomata as suggested by Artschwager (2) were made and counts of the number of plants reverting and of the num-
ber dying were maintained for 4 months. The results of this entire experiment are presented in figure 1.
1 Contributio n from th e Beet Seed Breedin g Department , Holly Suga r Corpora-
2Assoeiate Agronomis t and formerly J u n i o r Agronomist , respectively. Credit is
due A. E. Artschwager, Division of Sugar P l a n t s , U.S.D.A., for suggestions in con-ducting these experiments and for cytological examinations of the polyploids induced by ethyl mercury phosphate.
3 Figure s in parenthese s refer to Literatur e Cited.
In general, the data included in figure 1 show that, as the soak-
ing time or the concentration was increased, the number of plants produced was decreased but the percentage of polyploids obtained was increased. The amount of reversion taking place was not great in most cases but the death rate rapidly increased with the number of polyploids produced, so that at the end of 4 months only a small portion of the induced polyploids remained from any one treatment.
Miscellaneous Preliminary Experiments
Hormone Treatment of Colchicine Induced Polyploids.
noticeable in the polyploids induced by soaking the seed in solutions of colchicine that root development was greatly retarded. Six groups of polyploids induced by this method were transplanted and the roots treated with commercial preparations of indolebutyric acid in an at-tempt to overcome the retarded root development. No apparent value resulted from these hormone treatments.
X-Ray Seed Treatment.
—Three X-ray exposures were made of
8 lots of beet seed ranging from 0 to 36 seconds. One hundred seed-balls were planted of each lot after each exposure, making a total of 24 lots containing X-ray exposures of 0 to 108 seconds. Good germination was obtained in every case. The development of the seed-
lings was closely observed for the appearance of polyploids, but they appeared to be normal in every respect.
Ethyl-Mercury-Phosphate Seed Treatment.
—A series of experi-
ments indicated that a commercial seed-treating dust containing 5-percent ethyl mercury phosphate would induce polyploidy in sugar beets. Beet seed soaked for 48 hours in solutions of this dust con-taining from .00001 to .001-percent ethyl mercury phosphate pro-duced from 2 to 42 percent polyploids. A number of comparisons
were made of a .001-percent ethyl-mercury-phosphate solution and a
1-percent colchicine solution, soaking the beet seed for 24, 30, and 48
hours. It was noticeable that the polyploids induced by the ethyl-mercury-phosphate treatments were more vigorous than those induced by colchicine and the death loss was considerably less. However, a larger percentage of these plants reverted to normal so that the final percentage of polyploids remaining after 4 months was approximate-ly the same for the 2 chemicals.
Ethyl-Mercury-Phosphate Soil Treatment.
—A series of experi-
ments was conducted applying a commercial dust containing 5-per-cent ethyl mercury phosphate to the soil. Applications were made of from .005 to .1 gram of ethyl mercury phosphate per row foot direct-ly below the seed, with the seed, directly above the seed, and on top of the soil surface. Polyploids were obtained in all experiments and further experiments showed that polyploids may be produced in abun-
dance by applying .05 gram per row foot on top of, the soil directly above the seed and scratching it into the soil sufficiently to prevent
washing. The number of polyploids obtained is dependent on the va-riety of beet seed used, varying as much as 50 percent between vari-eties.
Calcium phosphate was also investigated by this procedure but
Sulfa Compounds and Other Irrigation Treatments.
—A series of
experiments was conducted in the greenhouse in which sugar beets
were planted in pots and irrigated continuously for 2 months with solutions of .005-percent sulfanilamide, .0077-percent sulfapyridine, .02-percent colchicine, and .00005-percent ethyl mercury phosphate. Polyploids were obtained from all treatments but continual contact of the colchicine and the ethyl-mercury-phosphate solutions proved to be toxic to young seedlings and they died. The growth of the plants in the sulfa treatments was very slow and at the age of 4 months,
after treatments had been discontinued for 2 months, these plants were only 1/4 to 1/2 inch in diameter.
Colchicine-Agar Crown and Branch Treatment.
concentrations of from .5 to 2.0 percent added to 1-percent agar as suggested by Artschwager (2) was applied with a brush to the crowns of stecklings to produce seed-bearing polyploid tissue. The crown buds were retarded and the plants began dying after a few days of
growth. This loss continued until only a few plants survived to shed pollen and these failed to produce seed.
Colchicine agar was also applied to open flowers and tips of
branches of seed beets and viable seed was obtained from all treat-ments in about equal amounts. Three times as many polyploid plants were obtained from the seed of the treated tips as from the seed of the treated open flowers. Twice as many plants were obtained from
the 1.5-pereent concentration as from the other treatments.
Following the procedure suggested by Peto (4), capsules con-
taining 1.0 and 1.5-percent colchicine agar were placed on decapitated branches. Pollen examinations as suggested by Abegg (1) were made
and from 2 to 3 dozen polyploid seedballs per plant were obtained from the new growth adjacent to each capsule.
Capsules containing a .001-percent ethyl-mercury-phosphate agar
were also used, but the tips were killed and the new growth arising
Colchicine Crown Injection Treatment.
—Three mm. of a 0.2-per-
cent solution of colchicine were injected into the crowns of steckiings. The results were similar to the agar treatment inasmuch as the plants
soon began dying off; although a few plants survived to produce pol-len, no seed was obtained.
308 AMERICAN SOCIETY SUGAR-BEET TECHNOLOGISTS
Colchicine Branch Immersion Treatment.
—Ten cc. portions of
from 0.5 to 2.0-percent colchicine solutions were placed in test tubes and branches of seedstalks immersed for from 1 to 48 hours. Seed was obtained from all treatments. The 16 and 24-hour treatments
produced about 8 times as many plants as other treatments and the 16-hour treatment produced 5 times as many polyploids as other treat-ments. The 1.5-percent concentration produced twice as many poly-ploids as the other treatments.
A similar experiment using from .0005 to .001-percent ethyl-
mercury-phosphate solutions was conducted but no polyploids were obtained.
Colchicine Branch Spray Treatment.
—An excess of solutions of
colchicine of from 1.5 to 5.0 percent was sprayed on to branches of seedstalks by atomizers and about equal amounts of seed were obtained from all treatments, while 1.0 and 2.0-percent concentrations produced 3 times as many polyploids as other concentrations. Seed from treat-
ed tips produced 2.5 times as many polyploids as the seed from treat-ed open flowers. Further experiments comparing the use of 1-per-cent colchicine and .0005-percent ethyl mercury phosphate for spray-ing entire plants on 181 plants showed that 10 percent of the plants produced polyploid pollen after 2 sprayings with colchicine as com-
pared to 8 percent for ethyl mercury phosphate after 4 sprayings.
The results of 66 treatments of sugar-beet seed in colchicine solu-
tions are presented showing the number of polyploids obtained after 4 months to be quite limited from all treatments. Hormone treat-ments failed to overcome retarded root development of the polyploids. Twenty-four X-ray seed treatments gave negative results. Seed-soak-ing treatments of concentrations of ethyl mercury phosphate also in-duced polyploids. Calcium phosphate was not effective. Irrigation treatments of sulfapyridine and sulfanilamide solutions induced poly-ploids. Crown injections and crown agar treatments of colchicine in-duced polyploid tissue in the seed-bearing generation. Comparisons oF concentrations of colchicine agar applied to the tips of branches indicated that the 1.5-percent concentration is the most effective. Polyploid seed was obtained from the use of 1.0 and 1.5-percent col-chicine-agar capsules; 0.001-percent ethyl-mercury-phosphate agar used in capsules killed the tissue. The results of immersing tips of branches in concentrations of colchicine solutions indicated that a 1.5-
percent solution for 16 hours is the most effective. Ethyl-mercury-
phosphate capsules did not induce polyploidy.
In the treatment of seed with colchicine, ethyl mercury phos-
phate, or other chemicals to produce polyploids the mortality rate in the early seedling stage is very great. The root development of the seedlings is limited and they do not survive this early period of growth very well. Those seedlings which do survive have all the first
season in which they may revert to normal. If they survive the first season there is opportunity for losses in storage and subsequent trans-planting. The production of polyploid seed directly through the treatment of the inflorescence appears to be the most promising pro-cedure for obtaining polyploid sugar beets.
1. Abegg, F. A. The Induction of Polyploidy in Beta vul
by Colchicine Treatment, Proc. Anier. Soc. Sugar Beet Tech-nologists, Jan. 1940. pp. 118-119.
2. Artschwager, E. A. Indications of Polyploidy in Sugar Beets
Induced by Colchicine. Proc. Amer. Soc. Sugar Beet Tech-
3. Blakeslee, A. F. and A. G. Avery. Methods of Inducing Doubling
of Chromosomes in Plants. Jour. Heredity, 28 : 393-411. 1937.
4. Peto, F. H. and J. W. Boyes. Comparison of Diploid and Tri-
ploid Sugar Beets. Can. Jour. of Res., 18 : 273-282. 1940.
Evaluation of Polyploid Strains Derived From
Curly-Top Resistant and Leafspot-
Resistant Sugar-Beet Varieties
With the discovery that polyploid types of plants can be pro-
duced readily by use of colchicine, great interest has attached to the application of this new technique to various economic plants. Meth-ods of inducing polyploidy in sugar beets have been previously de-
scribed.2 (1). It is now possible to report results from 2 years of comparative yield tests with 4 n
strains derived from the important diploid varieties II. S. 22, U. S. 23, and U. S. 215.
1Associate Geneticist, Division of Suga r Plan t Investigations , Burea u of Plan t
I n d u s t r y , United States Department of Agriculture.
2 Th e write r wishes to expres s his appreciatio n to Dr. G. H. Coons, Principa l
Pathologist, Division of Sugar Plant Investigations, U. S. Department of Agricul-ture, for suggestions and criticisms d u r i n g the progress of this work and in con-nection with the preparation of the manuscript.
Guidelines for Counseling Women on the Management of Menopause By the Jacobs Institute of Women's Health Expert Panel on Menopause Counseling Produced in Collaboration with The National Committee for Quality Assurance, The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, and The North American Menopause Society February 2000 Panel Members William C. Andrews, MD, FACOG, Co-Chair East
Onium Chemicals B.V., The Netherlands T.: +31(0)6 20171394; F.: +31(0)847233093; Mail : [email protected] Productlist API based on product in alphabetical For products detailed specifications or MSDS, please contact us by email to [email protected] PRODUCT NAME APPLICATION 7689-03-4 (+)-Camptothecin 200815-49-2 (R,R)-Formoterol-L-(+)-Tartrate 826